Spreadsheet, Database or Dedicated App? Choosing Where a Process Should Live
Plenty of businesses outgrow their spreadsheet and jump straight to expensive software. The middle options often fit better, and the jump is easier when you know the signs.
Most small businesses run something important in a spreadsheet: orders, stock, a customer list, a project plan. It works well, until it does not. The question is what to move to, and when.
The three options
A spreadsheet is flexible and familiar. A shared database, the kind with forms and linked tables, adds structure while staying adjustable. A dedicated app is built for one job and brings workflows, permissions and reports ready-made.
| Spreadsheet | Shared database | Dedicated app | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Setup effort | Minutes | Hours to days | Days to weeks |
| Handles many users at once | Poorly | Reasonably | Well |
| Rules and permissions | Minimal | Some | Built in |
| Fits an unusual process | Very well | Well | Only if it matches |
| Typical cost | Low or free | Low to medium | Medium to high |
Signs you have outgrown the spreadsheet
Two people overwrite each other's changes. Nobody is sure which version is current. The same data is typed in three places. A mistake in one cell caused a costly error. If two or more of these sound familiar, move.
Move one step, not three
The usual mistake is jumping straight to a dedicated app that does far more than needed. A shared database often solves the problem for a fraction of the cost and keeps your own process intact. Move to a dedicated app when the process is standard, the team is growing and you want reporting and permissions without building them.
Pick the smallest tool that fixes the problem you actually have.
Keep an exit
Whatever you choose, make sure you can export to a simple file. Today's database is next year's spreadsheet again.
Keep reading
More from the Comparisons desk
-
Comparisons Build or Buy? When Off-the-Shelf Software Stops Fitting
Building your own tool sounds like the way to get exactly what you need. For most small businesses it is the expensive route. Here is how to tell the rare cases where it is not.
-
Guides How to Switch Software Without Losing Your Data
Moving to a new tool is mostly a data problem. A clear plan, a trial run and a short overlap period make the switch far less risky than a single big cut-over.
-
Reviews What to Test in a Free Trial Before You Pay
Most trials are wasted clicking around. A short plan, built from the jobs the tool must do for you, tells you in a week whether it deserves a place in the business.
Join the readership
Liked this? Let's connect.
We respect your privacy. One considered email each Thursday.